Javier Milei wins Argentina election

Javier Milei wins Argentina election

Author
Discussion

Tankrizzo

7,090 posts

188 months

Yesterday (16:26)
quotequote all
I just don't get the whole "I believe in small state and not being told what to do by faceless bureaucrats" which is then followed by "belief in God is the cornerstone of a decent hierarchy". Surely one runs counter to the other.

JuanCarlosFandango

7,316 posts

66 months

Yesterday (16:29)
quotequote all
Civic
Is it automatically better in North Korea? Or under the Arab Socialist Ba'arth Party in Syria? Cuba or Hamas?

"The right" certainly don't have a monopoly on being poor judges of character, or leading countries to disaster.

2xChevrons
On that basis the net result of Nazi rule was a massive increase in the size and scope of the state, central planning, rationing and restrictions on trade, which could be seen as left wing.


silentbrown

8,479 posts

111 months

Yesterday (16:55)
quotequote all
Tankrizzo said:
I just don't get the whole "I believe in small state and not being told what to do by faceless bureaucrats" which is then followed by "belief in God is the cornerstone of a decent hierarchy". Surely one runs counter to the other.
thumbup God is the ultimate faceless bureaucrat.


RichTT

Original Poster:

2,867 posts

166 months

Yesterday (17:05)
quotequote all
Tankrizzo said:
I just don't get the whole "I believe in small state and not being told what to do by faceless bureaucrats" which is then followed by "belief in God is the cornerstone of a decent hierarchy". Surely one runs counter to the other.
I think the idea would be that religion teaches us each how to properly use the freedom that we have, whereas libertarianism merely clarifies what freedom is.

tangerine_sedge

4,469 posts

213 months

Yesterday (17:26)
quotequote all
RichTT said:
I think the idea would be that religion teaches us each how to properly use the freedom that we have, whereas libertarianism merely clarifies what freedom is.
The freedom to rape little boys, then get your bishop to cover it up? To commit genocide and kill those people who believe in different things? To restrict certain parts of society and ensure your 'lot' retain control?

Religion should be kept out of politics, it brings nothing but hate and division.

Castrol for a knave

4,186 posts

86 months

Yesterday (17:37)
quotequote all
RichTT said:
Tankrizzo said:
I just don't get the whole "I believe in small state and not being told what to do by faceless bureaucrats" which is then followed by "belief in God is the cornerstone of a decent hierarchy". Surely one runs counter to the other.
I think the idea would be that religion teaches us each how to properly use the freedom that we have, whereas libertarianism merely clarifies what freedom is.
Through the eons, religion and freedom have not been common bedfellows.

theplayingmantis

3,474 posts

77 months

Yesterday (19:21)
quotequote all
wc98 said:
hairykrishna said:
That's not really the case any more, at least in my experience. All the ordinary Argentinians I know are pretty vocal about the fact that they've had a useless shower in charge for far too long.
That's good to hear, the above was some time ago.
So why make your initial comment if it comes from a position of ultimately utter ignorance?!

OutInTheShed

6,265 posts

21 months

Yesterday (21:04)
quotequote all
Tankrizzo said:
I just don't get the whole "I believe in small state and not being told what to do by faceless bureaucrats" which is then followed by "belief in God is the cornerstone of a decent hierarchy". Surely one runs counter to the other.
I'm hoping this is a new trend , resulting in Ted Nugent becoming POTUS.
You gotta try it...

JuanCarlosFandango

7,316 posts

66 months

Yesterday (21:45)
quotequote all
Amazingly for a far right leader he looks less scary with a moustache




hidetheelephants

21,542 posts

188 months

Yesterday (21:57)
quotequote all
JuanCarlosFandango said:
Amazingly for a far right leader he looks less scary with a moustache

He could have a 2nd career as a Robert Shaw lookalike when he gets turfed out by the electorate after they discover his ideas are impractical nonsense.

F1GTRUeno

6,182 posts

213 months

Yesterday (23:15)
quotequote all
RichTT said:
Tankrizzo said:
I just don't get the whole "I believe in small state and not being told what to do by faceless bureaucrats" which is then followed by "belief in God is the cornerstone of a decent hierarchy". Surely one runs counter to the other.
I think the idea would be that religion teaches us each how to properly use the freedom that we have, whereas libertarianism merely clarifies what freedom is.
Being told what (mainly not) to do doesn't sound like freedom

RichTT

Original Poster:

2,867 posts

166 months

tangerine_sedge said:
RichTT said:
I think the idea would be that religion teaches us each how to properly use the freedom that we have, whereas libertarianism merely clarifies what freedom is.
The freedom to rape little boys, then get your bishop to cover it up? To commit genocide and kill those people who believe in different things? To restrict certain parts of society and ensure your 'lot' retain control?

Religion should be kept out of politics, it brings nothing but hate and division.
Not sure how you drew that from my explanation. Those things are wholly out with the concept of libertarianism, and to be honest, Christianity as well. That it happens is not the fault of the rules that they should follow.

All libertarians begin with a conception of personal autonomy from which they argue in favor of civil liberties and a reduction or elimination of the state.

Secondly of importance is the concept of property. That includes ownership over your own physical body and the products of its labor.

Things that would, and should be set out in law to punish those who transgress against those basic fundamental rights of freedom. Bearing also in mind that Milei is technically an Ancap (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho-capitalism) and is more in line with the ethics of the Non Aggression Principle.

On the moral point of view, the ten commandments would prohibit both of those.

THOU SHALT NOT KILL. - unjust killing; suicide; abortion; sterilization; dueling; endangering life and limb of self or others.
THOU SHALT NOT STEAL. - theft; damage to the property of others

In 2020 Milei called Pope Francis an “imbecile” and “the representative of the Evil One on earth” because he defends “social justice.”

He has also called Pope Francis a “filthy leftist,” an “embarrassing communist,” a “piece of st” and a “potato.” (The Spanish word for “pope” also means “potato.”)

So he has no particular love for the catholic state as an institution it would appear.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/16/world/americas/...


Edited by RichTT on Wednesday 22 November 04:15